Pleasant Valley, NY 12569

Property

Ownership: For Sale
Type: Single Family
Rooms: 11
Bedrooms: 6 BR
Bathrooms: 3½
Lot Size: 17.4 Acres

Financials

Price:$1,750,000
Annual Taxes:$25,969.95
2415 Montauk Highway PO Box 742, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
Listing Courtesy of Skyler Realty LLC

Step back in time without sacrificing modern comforts in this rare, historic brick farmhouse estate, originally built in the 1760s by early settler Sarah Tobias Newcomb.

View of front of home with a gambrel roof, a front yard, a chimney, and roof with shingles

View of front of home with a gambrel roof, a front yard, a chimney, and roof with shingles

View of front of home with a gambrel roof, a front yard, a chimney, and roof with shingles
View of front of home with a gambrel roof, a front yard, a chimney, and roof with shingles
View of front of property with a front lawn, a chimney, and brick siding
View of subject property
Corridor featuring light wood-style flooring, ornamental molding, and stairs
Hallway featuring stairway, ornamental molding, and hardwood / wood-style floors
Living area featuring ornamental molding, wood finished floors, and a fireplace
Living area with a chandelier, light wood-style floors, and ornamental molding
Living area featuring a chandelier, hardwood / wood-style flooring, ornamental molding, and a fireplace
Dining room with a chandelier, light wood-type flooring, ornamental molding, and a fireplace
Office space featuring light wood-style flooring, crown molding, a fireplace with flush hearth, and a chandelier
Kitchen with wall chimney exhaust hood, a chandelier, light wood finished floors, pendant lighting, and crown molding
Kitchen with high quality appliances, wall chimney exhaust hood, hanging light fixtures, a chandelier, and crown molding
Kitchen with range with two ovens, wall chimney exhaust hood, wooden counters, and decorative light fixtures
Bedroom with a chandelier, ornamental molding, wood finished floors, and a lit fireplace
Bedroom featuring a chandelier, light wood-style floors, and crown molding
Bedroom with crown molding, a chandelier, wood finished floors, and a lit fireplace
Full bath with vanity, a shower stall, and a chandelier
Sitting room featuring light wood-style flooring, a chandelier, and crown molding
Full bath with a shower stall, vanity, crown molding, and recessed lighting
Bathroom with vanity, ornamental molding, a shower stall, a bath, and recessed lighting
Bathroom featuring vanity and baseboards
Bedroom with crown molding, a fireplace, and wood finished floors
Bedroom with wallpapered walls, wood finished floors, and a baseboard heating unit
Bedroom featuring wallpapered walls
View of side of property with a yard and driveway
View of patio / terrace with view of wooded area, a water view, and outdoor lounge area
View of front of home with a gambrel roof, a front yard, a chimney, and roof with shinglesView of front of home with a gambrel roof, a front yard, a chimney, and roof with shinglesView of front of property with a front lawn, a chimney, and brick sidingView of subject propertyCorridor featuring light wood-style flooring, ornamental molding, and stairsHallway featuring stairway, ornamental molding, and hardwood / wood-style floorsLiving area featuring ornamental molding, wood finished floors, and a fireplaceLiving area with a chandelier, light wood-style floors, and ornamental moldingLiving area featuring a chandelier, hardwood / wood-style flooring, ornamental molding, and a fireplaceDining room with a chandelier, light wood-type flooring, ornamental molding, and a fireplace

Description

Step back in time without sacrificing modern comforts in this rare, historic brick farmhouse estate, originally built in the 1760s by early settler Sarah Tobias Newcomb. Rich in Revolutionary War-era history, this extraordinary property tells a story few homes can: Sarah famously sent cheese from her dairy to George Washington's encampment nearby. Over the years, the home has flown both British and American flags, bearing witness to centuries of change. Set on approximately 18 serene acres with subdivision potential for three 3.5-acre lots, the estate includes a beautifully restored 6-bedroom, 4-bathroom residence. Carefully updated to preserve its character, the home features original wide-plank hardwood floors, massive Dutch doors with original hardware, six corner Rumford fireplaces, designer lighting, crown molding, and a fully renovated chef’s kitchen with an eat-in area. Enjoy formal and casual living spaces, including a dining room, living room, and family room. Modern upgrades include new central air, central vacuum, and oil heating with an above-ground tank. Additional amenities include a soaking tub, stall shower, and dedicated dressing area. Property taxes have been lowered for the 2025 tax season, offering immediate financial relief—and there is further potential for tax breaks should the new owner choose to start a small farm operation. Outdoors, unwind on the 50-foot veranda overlooking a tranquil pond and rolling pastures. A charming tiny house by a seasonal brook offers extra retreat space, while two large barns serve various purposes—one equipped with horse stalls and a commercial woodworking shop, the other perfect for additional stabling or storage. An outdoor cabana adds another space for relaxation or entertaining. This estate is being sold as-is by motivated sellers who have poured love and care into its restoration. Whether you're an equestrian, a history enthusiast, or a visionary investor, this property offers endless potential—from farming (which may bring additional tax benefits) to development or simply enjoying the luxury of rural elegance.

Amenities

  • Balcony
  • Bedroom
  • Blinds
  • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
  • Central Vacuum
  • Chandelier
  • Chefs Kitchen
  • Corner Lot
  • Courtyard
  • Crown Molding
  • Dishwasher
  • Double Vanity
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • Entertainment Cabinets
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Exhaust Fan
  • Family Room
  • First Floor Bedroom
  • Formal Dining
  • Front Yard
  • Gas Range
  • High ceiling
  • Kitchen Island
  • Level
  • Lighting
  • Living Room
  • Natural Woodwork
  • Near Public Transit
  • Near School
  • Near Shops
  • Oil Water Heater
  • Original Details
  • Pantry
  • Part Wooded
  • Pond
  • Primary Bathroom
  • Recessed Lighting
  • Refrigerator
  • Security Gate
  • Security System
  • Sloped
  • Smart Thermostat
  • Soaking Tub
  • Speakers
  • Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
  • Stone/Brick Wall
  • Trash Collection Private
  • Trees/Woods
  • Views
  • Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Wall of Windows
  • Water
  • Wine Refrigerator
  • Wood Burning
  • Wood Frames

Long Island MLS

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. International currency conversions where shown are estimates based on recent exchange rates and are not official asking prices.

All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.