Shelter Island, NY 11964

Property

Ownership: For Sale
Type: Single Family
Rooms: 14
Bedrooms: 4 BR
Bathrooms:
Lot Size: 2.2 Acres

Financials

Price:$3,499,000
Annual Taxes:$11,090.58
25 Nugent Street, Southampton, NY 11968, USA
Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Greater

Welcome to Shelter Island a place where time slows down and nature takes center stage.

Spacious interior featuring wood-finish flooring and white walls
Spacious bedroom featuring vaulted ceilings, wood-finish flooring, two large windows, an overhead chandelier, and a white paneled door
Living area featuring dark wood-finish flooring, white trim, and a decorative chandelier
Integrated jetted tub set within a marble-clad platform with steps, flanked by decorative columns
Spacious kitchen featuring two large islands with integrated wine storage and a sink
Spacious kitchen and dining area featuring light-toned tile flooring, recessed lighting, and a bay window with arched transoms
Expansive wood-finish deck with cedar shake siding, multiple exterior access points, and a covered patio area below a second-story balcony
Spacious outdoor deck with natural wood planks and matching railings
Vaulted ceiling room featuring light wood-finish flooring and a trio of windows
Bathroom featuring a dual vanity with vessel sinks, ornate framed mirror, integrated soaking tub, and extensive floor-to-ceiling stone tiling
Expansive green lawn bordering a stone-clad residence with multiple chimneys, a dark shingle roof, and a rear deck featuring white-framed glass doors
Shingle-sided exterior featuring an upper-level balcony, covered front entry with columns, multiple arched window sets, and a stone chimney
Spacious interior featuring wood-finish flooring and white wallsSpacious bedroom featuring vaulted ceilings, wood-finish flooring, two large windows, an overhead chandelier, and a white paneled doorLiving area featuring dark wood-finish flooring, white trim, and a decorative chandelierIntegrated jetted tub set within a marble-clad platform with steps, flanked by decorative columnsSpacious kitchen featuring two large islands with integrated wine storage and a sinkSpacious kitchen and dining area featuring light-toned tile flooring, recessed lighting, and a bay window with arched transomsExpansive wood-finish deck with cedar shake siding, multiple exterior access points, and a covered patio area below a second-story balconySpacious outdoor deck with natural wood planks and matching railings

Description

Welcome to Shelter Island — a place where time slows down and nature takes center stage. Accessible only by ferry, this rare island community offers a level of peace, privacy, and authenticity that is nearly impossible to find in today’s world. Set on over 2 acres of beautifully engineered rolling landscape, this property has been thoughtfully designed to enhance natural beauty while addressing elevation and drainage for long-term peace of mind. Bordering the historic Sylvester Manor, the property enjoys direct proximity to preserved land, scenic walking trails, and a setting rich in history and natural beauty—ensuring both privacy and a protected backdrop that will remain timeless. Surrounded by open skies, coastal breezes, and abundant wildlife, this is a setting where mornings begin with birdsong and evenings end under starlit skies. Enjoy biking along quiet roads, swimming in nearby freshwater lakes, boating, fishing, or simply relaxing with a book as the day slips away. Unlike the increasingly crowded Hamptons, Shelter Island preserves the essence of what made the East End special—unspoiled, understated, and deeply connected to nature. With limited inventory and growing demand, opportunities like this are increasingly rare. Whether as a private retreat, legacy property, or long-term investment, this offering represents more than real estate—it’s a lifestyle “Private Shelter Island retreat minutes from the Hamptons and North ferry-only exclusivity, privacy, wellness, retreat feel, boating, escape from overdeveloped Hamptons

Amenities

  • Cable - Available
  • Cable Connected
  • Chefs Kitchen
  • Convection Oven
  • Cooktop
  • Dishwasher
  • Dryer
  • Electricity Connected
  • Exhaust Fan
  • Family Room
  • First Floor Bedroom
  • First Floor Full Bath
  • Freezer
  • Gas Cooktop
  • Gas Range
  • Living Room
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Propane
  • Refrigerator
  • Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
  • Trash Collection Public
  • Washer
  • Wood Burning

Long Island MLS

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. International currency conversions where shown are estimates based on recent exchange rates and are not official asking prices.

All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.