North Haven is a tiny town located on an island just south of Shelter Island and north of Sag Harbor. Being a small residential community, North Haven prides itself on being quaint, private, and isolated. The town doesn’t have many stores or restaurants or the traditional amenities one might usually expect but instead has the charm of a small town, along with beautiful houses, gorgeous sea views, and, of course, wonderful sea breeze that attracts people every year longing for an escape from the mayhem and heat of New York City in the summer.
The Secret Garden
$10,000October 1-31st 2026
Beautiful 4 Bedroom in Sag Harbor
$70,000April through Labor Day 2026
$20,000August 1st to Labor Day 2026
$38,000July 1st thru Labor Day 2026
$18,000July 1-31st 2026
$30,000June-July 2026
$20,000June 1-30th 2026
$60,000May through Labor Day 2026
$50,000Memorial Day to Labor Day 2026
$5,000November 1-30th 2026
$6,000October 1-31st 2026
$12,000September 1-30th 2026
$90,000Year round 2026
North Haven Home With Bay Views!
$115,000July 1-31st
$125,000August 1-31st
$250,000July 1st thru Labor Day
$500,000Year round
Estate in Sag Harbor
$265,000July 1st thru Labor Day
Recently Renovated Traditional Home close to Bay Beach!
$65,000July 1-31st
Sag Harbor Private and Secluded
$60,000July 1-31st
$75,000August 1st to Labor Day
$70,000August 1-31st
Peaceful retreat awaits in Sag Harbor-Your own secluded getaway!
$85,000July 1st thru Labor Day
$50,000August 1st to Labor Day
$40,000July 1-31st
$50,000August 1-31st
North Haven Retreat and Getaway
$34,000August 1st to Labor Day
$20,000September 1-30th
$32,000July 1-31st
$60,000July 1st thru Labor Day
Lovely 2 bedroom home in Sag Harbor!
$23,000July 1-31st
Bayfront Sag Harbor Traditional
$11,000Short term
Sag Harbor Private and Secluded
$75,000August 1st to Labor Day 2026
11 found