Sheepshead Bay Houses For Sale

Sheepshead Bay

With some twenty blocks of waterfront on its southern side, Sheepshead Bay is a community that was once a summer getaway for many New Yorkers. The neighborhood was named after the bay that separates the mainland of Brooklyn from the eastern border of Coney Island. The area is home to many residents of Eastern European decent which gives its diverse cultural identity.

The neighborhood’s namesake, Sheepshead Bay, was named for the Sheepshead, an edible fish found in the bay's waters. New Yorkers summered on Brooklyn’s Gold Coast, a long swath of beach stretching from Coney Island to the far eastern end of Sheepshead Bay. The area was dotted with fancy hotels, casinos, racetracks and other rowdy, turn-of-the-century attractions. The area is also home to the Holocaust Memorial Park, New York’s First Public Memorial to the Holocaust. Some notable names that are from the area include Larry David from “Curb Your Enthusiasm” and TV star Judge Judy.

There are a number of neighborhood eateries in the neighborhood with Avenue U offering several Chinese bakeries; Long Wong is a go-to spot for a quick breakfast that includes buns. Brennan & Carr, a culinary landmark since the 1930’s serves roast beef sandwiches and burgers in the borough, famous for its double-dip technique, a process that gets the entire roast beef sandwich sopping wet with a famous broth.

There’s a mix of large and small homes, some of Brooklyn’s most extravagant single-family homes along Ocean Parkway, low-rises and traditional brick houses that stand next to glassy new high-rises. A 30-story luxury condo tower is under construction with listings ranging from $730K for a 1-bedroom to $2.2M for the penthouse. It’s the first building of its kind in Sheepshead Bay, and will offer many amenities, including an outdoor swimming pool. Average rent is below $1700 monthly.

Most commuters living in Sheepshead Bay apartments either drive their car into the city or get rides to the subway via a car or bus. Running along the eastern side of the neighborhood are the B and Q subway lines, which can be accessed from four stations.

Rarely available ! ! A spectacular architectural masterpiece reflecting detailed sophistication situated on a sprawling 100 x 100 lot on the corner of the exclusive Hampton Avenue.$6,595,000
Video appointments available just reach out to the listing agent to schedule a virtual showing.$3,995,000
Brand new to the market !$2,698,000
NEW LISTING Hasn't been on the market since 1930 !$895,000
This property is a great renovation opportunity.$2,450,000
Welcome to 2750 East 26th Street.$1,290,000
First time on the market in over 40 years.$1,690,000
Built in 2009, this gorgeous and modern smart home is truly one of a kind !$1,800,000
Welcome to Emmons Avenue in Sheepshead Bay.$1,720,000
New Listing Sheepshead Bay !$739,000
Stately and spacious, you will love this legal two family in Brooklyn.$1,269,000
Lot 40x104, gut renovated in 2020 legal 2 family with fully finished basement featuring open concept floor plans, gym, steam shower, Italian kitchen and appliances, Mirage Canadian hardwood floors throughout, ...$2,199,999
Welcome to 215 Coleridge Street, a beautiful fully detached single family home located on one of Manhattan Beach's most desirable ocean blocks.$1,675,000
If you are Looking for a 20 FT Wide House, Look No Further.$983,000
This unique, detached, three story, single family 5 bedroom, 4.$1,099,000
Welcome to 2232 East 7th Street in the highly desirable Ocean Parkway District of the Sheepshead Bay Gravesend section of Brooklyn.$2,495,000
If you are looking for a 20 ft wide house, look no further.$973,000
Stunning detached 2 Family home in the heart of Marina Park.$925,000
Welcome to 2371 Bragg Street, located in prime Sheepshead Bay this two family turn key brick home is the perfect place to call home.$850,000
20 found


The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the OneKey Multiple Listing Service. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Nest Seekers International are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.

Information Copyright 2021, ONEKEY™ MLS, LLC.